Skip to main content

Part 3 of What needs to be done to get INDIA back into 8% growth .... Free markets and confusions relating to it

Free markets allow for everyone to have access to all factors of production equally, for prices to be determined fairly and for anyone to have the ability to enter and exit any business. 

Free markets have a very bad press in the liberal left media. Paraphrasing Winston Churchill’s famous quote on democracy “free markets is the worst form of economic system except the rest”... 
They are associated with the wild west , robber barons, monopolistic oligarchs and high level of inequality, among other evils. Nothing could be further from the truth. 
These are all situations of jungle raj (might is right) and not rule of law. 
Let’s take each one of them and prove that they were not free markets. If readers are to take away one thing for. This article , it should be that.

The west west was not a free market because coercion and violence was used by the settlers to acquire land (which in an agrarian society was the main factor of production). So a critical determinant of free markets (prices to be determined fairly) was never met.

In our previous article , we have discussed why the Russian Oligarch system and the Chinese guanxi systems are not free market systems but system where the markets have been skewed in favour of a few who have captured the rule making / rule enforcing systems. 

The robber barons era in the US, when the industrial revolution was at its peak, was akin to the current monopolistic power that some tech companies such as Facebook and google are enjoying. Monopolies are coercive with customers and also the barrier to entry becomes very high. The robber baron era led to strong anti monopolistic regulations, which unfortunately large companies continue to try and skirt. 

Eternal vigilance to ensure that monopolies do not get created is the price to be paid to ensure that the principles of free markets (easy entry/exit and no coercion) are protected. Letting 
Free markets without any coercion are the polar opposite of jungle raj where power determines outcomes. 

powerful monopolies like Facebook buy WhatsApp and Instagram is a failure of these higher level principles.

While admittedly, there is a fudge involved in government interventions to prevent monopolies, and extremist free market theorists are against it, I believe it supports the higher principles but again eternal vigilance is required to ensure that the monopoly busters are not misusing their power (which is highly likely in the Indian bureaucracy). Like all practical things, balance is required. 

The Indian bureaucracy has a deep rooted suspicion of free markets and a deep seated socialist mindset. As a bureaucrat friend reminded me - the Indian politician is the body but the bureaucracy is the soul and the soul is indestructible !!

India is going through a cyclical slowdown. However, the creeping bureaucracy and command and control license raj creeping back in over the last few years (including the much discredited but strangely back in fashion price controls) and deep rooted suspicion of entrepreneurs is creating a structural slowdown as well. 
We should not waste this crisis and really exorcise this socialist “soul”out of the body of this country. 

This vicious cycle can be broken by simple and stable rules with little leeway for discretion or exceptions. India has to learn from the success of India’s biggest global success stories - IT and Pharma, where companies grew and were left alone to face market forces without government intervention. 

To be continued....Next article: how to leverage Indian entrepreneurial culture in nation building link to next article


Popular posts from this blog

Never Waste a Crisis

“ Never waste a good crisis “Winston Churchill.  There is no doubt that we are in the middle of unprecedented crisis globally. With almost 3 million people infected and over 200,000 people dead due to the corona virus.  Look at the headlines;  ·        German newspaper sends China USD 130 billion invoice against Corona Virus damage ·        Japan to offer billions to firms shifting production out of China ·        Trump warns China of consequences as Republicans and democrats fight over who is cozier with Beijing. It is evident to all but the most perma China bulls that global supply chains will now need a backup if not an alternative to China. The days of running a global factory with slave labour, financial repression (and therefore cheap capital), scant respect to the environment and a bully mercantilist mentality are now numbered. The world is truly unipolar now with China on one side and the rest of the world on the other. Look at the exports and imports

Part 1: What needs to be done to get INDIA back into 8% growth

Classical economic theory from the time of Adam Smith and Karl Marx considered the four factors of production as  Land, Labour , Capital and Entrepreneurship.  This model was appropriate for Basic agricultural and emerging industrial societies but can be tweaked to encompass factors which are relevant for the modern post industrial era as well.  For the economic machinery to operate in balance, there are two critical but implicit assumptions :  1)   Rule of law 2) Free Market  Think of the overall economy very simplistically as a very large box full of gears of different sizes - green gears for Land, red for labour and blue for capital and think of entrepreneurs as people who buy these different gears and connect them to a very large rotating shaft of  there   economy  which has a very large number of black gears of different sizes attached to it.  The job of the entrepreneur is to create his little machine of green red and blue gears and ensure that it’s connected to t

Part 2 of What needs to be done to get INDIA back into 8% growth .... Why is stable , fair and transparent Rule of Law critical for a well functioning economy

A stable, fair and transparent rule of law allows for 2 very important things : 1)  no coercion of any sort and 2) contracts can be enforced .  Let’s take the latter first. If contracts can be easily and timely enforced, it creates a high trust society, which increases efficiency all around. In the absence of ability to quickly and cheaply enforce contracts , societies rely on family and clans and their social enforcement mechanism like ostracism, which by definition reduces the talent and partners pool and therefore the size and output of the enterprise.  If entrepreneur 1 has setup a b2b business - supplying to entrepreneur 2 under a contract and entrepreneur 2 refuses to honour the contract for whatever reasons, entrepreneur 1’s business is impaired and if it takes years for restitution, many such businesses will not even start reducing the overall output. Therefore countries in which the legal system is slow, complex (like in India) and consequently expensive lose out by