Skip to main content

Part 5 of What needs to be done to get INDIA back into 8% growth .... land reforms needed to unleash India

China is on track to become the largest economy in the world on the back of massive industrialisation and movement of agricultural labour to factory workers to become the factory for the world. While India remains stubbornly rural with close to 50% of the population still dependent of agriculture. 

The zamindari abolition (redistribution of land to the tillers from absentee landlords) remains an unfinished agenda. The unfinished agenda report has been gathering dust for a decade being “studied” by the Indian bureaucracy. More than 10 million people remain landless labourers and sharecroppers. 
However, even if the redistribution (which is a state subject) were to be expedited, it is not going to be transformative. The increase in population and therefore fragmentation of holdings has led to a situation where an average farmer has less than 2 acres of land. This is a fraction of the minimum viable size to invest in mechanisation and has ensured that Indian agricultural remains one of the poorest in terms of yields (a third lower than the global average and just a quarter of the best of breed German farms for wheat for instance) and remains subsistence level. 

Because titles are not proper, possession remain 9/10th of the law and that hinders the movement of labour to cities and industries. Restriction of who can own agricultural land (in most states, its a hereditary right and non agriculturists and corporates can’t own agricultural land) has ensured that modern methods can’t be applied and yields and therefore surplus remains low. 

What is really required is easy availability of land to set up industries. Given fragmented holdings, it is very difficult for land to be aggregated by the private sector. 
I had visited a industrial cluster in China along with one of the companies on whose board I was. The local government official offered us ready build factory shed and a hostel for workers and said that if we wanted , we could start the NEXT day. This is the competition! 

However, the China , US rivalry is now structural and long term and global supply chains are looking for a new home as an alternative to China. But the beneficiaries so far have been the south East Asian countries. We need a massive push into creating land banks and single window clearance and not the typical Indian bureaucratic red tape. Otherwise, we are soon going to be hit with a demographic discount with armies of unemployed young people and the accompanying social strife (a part of which we are seeing on the streets already!). 

To be continued....Next article: criticality of labour reforms link to next article


Popular posts from this blog

Never Waste a Crisis

“ Never waste a good crisis “Winston Churchill.  There is no doubt that we are in the middle of unprecedented crisis globally. With almost 3 million people infected and over 200,000 people dead due to the corona virus.  Look at the headlines;  ·        German newspaper sends China USD 130 billion invoice against Corona Virus damage ·        Japan to offer billions to firms shifting production out of China ·        Trump warns China of consequences as Republicans and democrats fight over who is cozier with Beijing. It is evident to all but the most perma China bulls that global supply chains will now need a backup if not an alternative to China. The days of running a global factory with slave labour, financial repression (and therefore cheap capital), scant respect to the environment and a bully mercantilist mentality are now numbered. The world is truly unipolar now with China on one side and the rest of the world on the other. Look at the exports and imports

Part 1: What needs to be done to get INDIA back into 8% growth

Classical economic theory from the time of Adam Smith and Karl Marx considered the four factors of production as  Land, Labour , Capital and Entrepreneurship.  This model was appropriate for Basic agricultural and emerging industrial societies but can be tweaked to encompass factors which are relevant for the modern post industrial era as well.  For the economic machinery to operate in balance, there are two critical but implicit assumptions :  1)   Rule of law 2) Free Market  Think of the overall economy very simplistically as a very large box full of gears of different sizes - green gears for Land, red for labour and blue for capital and think of entrepreneurs as people who buy these different gears and connect them to a very large rotating shaft of  there   economy  which has a very large number of black gears of different sizes attached to it.  The job of the entrepreneur is to create his little machine of green red and blue gears and ensure that it’s connected to t

Part 2 of What needs to be done to get INDIA back into 8% growth .... Why is stable , fair and transparent Rule of Law critical for a well functioning economy

A stable, fair and transparent rule of law allows for 2 very important things : 1)  no coercion of any sort and 2) contracts can be enforced .  Let’s take the latter first. If contracts can be easily and timely enforced, it creates a high trust society, which increases efficiency all around. In the absence of ability to quickly and cheaply enforce contracts , societies rely on family and clans and their social enforcement mechanism like ostracism, which by definition reduces the talent and partners pool and therefore the size and output of the enterprise.  If entrepreneur 1 has setup a b2b business - supplying to entrepreneur 2 under a contract and entrepreneur 2 refuses to honour the contract for whatever reasons, entrepreneur 1’s business is impaired and if it takes years for restitution, many such businesses will not even start reducing the overall output. Therefore countries in which the legal system is slow, complex (like in India) and consequently expensive lose out by